Daughter gains 40 years in family torture and murder


April 1-Welch-The last chapter of the eerie story of torture, murder, and incest ended on Wednesday when the last family of a trio of father-daughter murderers was sentenced to 40 years in prison.

Anna Marie Choudhary, 33, from Boon, North Carolina, was sentenced to the highest sentence for a second murder by Judge Ed Cornish of the McDowell County Circuit Court. Choudhary pleaded guilty in January for killing John Thomas McGuire, 38, in McDowell County around February 14, 2019.

Larry Paul McClure Sr., 55, the father of Choudhary in Pendleton, Kentucky, and Amanda Michelle Naylor McClure, 31, the sister of Chisago City, Minnesota, have previously convicted their role in crime.

Larry McClure was found guilty of first-class murder and sentenced to life imprisonment in August 2020.

Amanda McClure was found guilty of the second murder and sentenced to 40 years in prison in October 2020.

Karen Smith, the adoptive parent of Choudhary in Minnesota and the mother of McGuire in Opelika, Alabama, attended the hearing on Wednesday through a conference call.

Mr Smith wanted the murderer confessed during the trial to be a “very miserable life,” said McDowell County prosecutor Denny Morgan.

“We want to have some kind of justice for our families,” Morgan said. “In the end, I thank Judge Cornish (Choudhary) for receiving the biggest decision. She deserved it.”

McGuire’s body was found on September 24, 2019 at the tomb of Skygusty’s residence after McClure revealed the murder to a West Virginia police soldier.

“If he (McClure) didn’t say it, they would have run away,” Morgan said. “They were running away with it for seven months.”

*** ***

The story of McGaia’s murder, full of family dysfunction, addiction and libido, was released from prison after Larry McClure was sentenced to more than 17 years in prison for child sexual abuse and moved to McDowell County. It started when I lived.

McClure was initially estranged from his daughter, Choudary, who lived in North Carolina, and Amanda, who lived with McGuire, Indiana. However, according to testimony in Larry McClure’s decision, everyone was involved in narcotics.

In the days prior to the murder, Larry McClure went to India with Choudary to pick up Amanda and John McGuire, who had problems with their vehicles due to “dope disease,” according to previous court testimony. I went by car. After that, the group headed for Sky Gasuti.

According to previous testimony, the group bought an item to make a stimulant, but it didn’t come out correctly and was a “bad batch.”

While this was happening, Larry McClure had what Choudary called “quiet anger.” He also “go sideways” and talked to Amanda. Choudhary also remembered that he had asked him to cut some ropes, and that he had done it before carrying the scrap metal, so nothing strange was seen about this.

At previous hearings, the families pointed at each other when it came to naming the murder mastermind.

In a statement by Judge Cornish, Larry McClure said in a hearing that the testimony was “all okay for the first 10 days.” “Thursday morning you were sitting on the balcony and Amanda came out and said she wanted to kill John.” And “She needed something like a rope …”

However, Choudhary said in a hearing of the ruling that things “began to become strange” after Valentine’s Day supper, where Larry McClure invited McGuire to play a “trust game.”

McGuire’s legs were tied up, and when he later moved to get out of the bondage, Amanda McClure hit his head with a bottle of wine, Choudary said.

“This game of trust was one of the most evil I’ve had,” said Prosecutor Assistant Morgan.

Larry McClure said McGuire’s torture began on Thursday, February 14, and continued until Saturday.

During this time, he was tied up by a pig, afflicted, injected with liquid methamphetamine, and later strangled.

“A black trash bag was wrapped around his head by Amanda,” said Larry McClure. “Anna strangled him … I hugged him.”

McClure described it as “a few days of hell.”

“Late that morning, we buried him in a two-foot grave behind the house,” he said.

Defendants also testified that the next day, McGuire’s body was dug up, dismantled, and re-burial.

—- A court document obtained by The Daily Telegraph in November 2019 revealed an incestuous relationship between Larry McClure and his daughter Amanda.

A criminal accusation filed by West Virginia Police Trooper KM Sadler revealed that Larry and Amanda McClure had sexual intercourse in Skygusty’s residence.

Three and a half weeks after McGuire’s murder, Larry and Amanda McClure crossed the border to neighboring Tazewell County, Virginia, where they married.

Choudhary testified that she went to Tazewell with her father and sister for the ceremony.

“They took me and said I needed to behave like a happy witness,” she said in a hearing.

During Amanda McClure’s trial, Smith questioned the motive behind the murder of his son.

“Mr. Smith, the only answer I can give you about why it happened is that John was with me,” said Amanda McClure. “My dad didn’t want anyone near me …

—- In Larry McClure’s decision, Cornish gave Smith the opportunity to address the death of his son in court.

“I forgive you because my god also told me, but I will never forget,” Smith stood in front of McClure and told him directly.

“You and your two kids go straight to hell!” She said. “Marrying your own daughter-it’s a lowdown …

“In my book, all three need to die! You don’t deserve to breathe on this planet …” Smith said violently. “I’m going to live to see you or one of your children die before you go … who gave you the right to play God?”

— Contact Samantha Perry at [email protected]

Posted on