Israeli Health Ministry Confirms Leaked Video Is Authentic, Releases False Statements


Israel’s health ministry has confirmed the authenticity of a leaked video showing an expert warning authorities that they could face lawsuits over side effects of the COVID-19 vaccine. , made a false statement about this discussion.

Video footage recorded during a conference held behind closed doors over the summer showed that experts hired to analyze post-vaccine adverse event reports showed a causal link between some of the events and the vaccine. He said he warned against presenting the data in certain ways to avoid lawsuits.

In an official report released about two months later in August, officials said, “This report shows all reported cases in close proximity to vaccination with the coronavirus vaccine, not necessarily in conjunction with vaccination. It does not indicate causality and the reported phenomenon.

The ministry or health ministry has repeatedly declined to comment to the Epoch Times about the video and did not respond to inquiries from health journalist and professor Yaffa Shir-Raz, who obtained the video from the source.

Officials present during the meeting also declined to comment or did not respond to comments and have not publicly commented on the situation.

An unnamed health ministry official now says the video is legal.pointed out to Reutersposted a clip of the meeting that Shir-Raz posted online, as well as a “fact check” on the social media post sharing the clip.

Officials did not say why key pieces of the discussion were left out of the final report. Officials claimed that all data presented during the meeting was in the final report.

“Meeting attendees can see that the sections have been taken out of context,” the official said. “The leaked clip was carefully selected and edited in a biased manner, so that when our support team first tried to understand it, we intentionally misrepresented the fact that this was a discussion of raw data that had not undergone analysis or normalization. Epidemiology experts can tell you how to proceed and analyze the raw data correctly.”

Shir-Raz told the Epoch Times that he found it interesting that an anonymous MoH source responded to Reuters.

“Unfortunately, the Ministry of Health does not have the courage to officially endorse responses, preferring instead to hide behind anonymous respondents,” she said in an email.


Health ministry officials made several falsehoods in their comments to Reuters.

For example, when the report was submitted to the new system, the analyzed report was erroneously stated as ‘not verifiable’. rice field.

The MoH also claims “no unknown side effects or new signals.”

But according to one of the presenters, Sasha Zhurat, that’s not true.

During the conference, she said the data “really allowed us to identify new phenomena such as tinnitus, such as hypesthesia and hypoesthesia,” adding that “there are a number of consumer concerns, such as vertigo, tinnitus, hypoesthesia, and paresthesia.” We really identified a new phenomenon that wasn’t shown in the brochure.”

Zhurat also pointed out that the pamphlets given to prospective vaccinees list a certain period of time during which side effects may occur.

The leaflet states that the problem “should be resolved within a few days, but we’ve found it’s not,” says Zhurat. I did.

Zhurat declined to comment on the discussion, telling The Epoch Times in a Facebook message that she is no longer part of the team analyzing the data.

Sharlaz said on Twitter Part of the meeting indicated that only one out of four health maintenance organizations (HMOs) in Israel provided reports of adverse events. The Ministry of Health said it had received reports from all her HMOs, or organizations providing healthcare to citizens.

HMO has not responded to requests for comment.

During the conference, the presenter said many of the reports came from one of the HMOs, Meuhedet. Another Maccabi said, “We didn’t send that much because they collected the phenomena themselves, not on your form,” said Maya Berlin, another member of the team.

Team leader Dr. Matty Berkovich said the point was “very important.” “This means there is an HMO of his who keeps the information secret,” he said.

In addition, according to a draft copy of the report finally released by the Ministry of Health, also obtained by Shir-Raz, one of the team said, “There are HMOs who did not send messages, so there is a bias in the messages. I question whether it should be pointed out that there is report? “

The final report does not mention this point.

“They could have reliably reported the number of reports from each HMO. Why didn’t they do that?” Shahraz wondered.

Recef Levy, a professor of operations management at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and an Israeli native who has been keeping a close eye on the situation, said the MoH “lost the trust of the Israeli public for precisely such actions.”

It will take new leadership and different actions to undo the tremendous damage that has been caused,” he told the Epoch Times in an email.

Epoch Times photo
The Thomson Reuters building in New York City in a 2011 file photo. (Spencer Pratt/Getty Images)

didn’t watch the video

Besides the health ministry official’s name not being identified, it is not clear who produced the Reuters “fact-checking”. The signature line reads “Reuters Staff”.

Reuters took aim at the released video clip, calling it a “fact check” and “misleading”.

However, a spokesperson confirmed that Reuters did not see the entire video.

“As stated in a Reuters fact-check, the Ministry of Health said the video clip shown online was of an internal meeting recorded without their knowledge and the full recording was not available,” Reuters said. spokesperson told the Epoch Times in an email. “Reuters supports reports that the edited clip published online was taken out of context and misleading.”

Reuters never approached Shir-Raz for the full record.

“As for Reuters, no one has contacted me for comment or to watch the recording. It’s amazing,” said Shir-Raz.

“In my investigation, the allegations of cover-up and lying are based on genuine recordings of discussions in which the speaker was unaware that they were being recorded and therefore spoke freely. This is the highest level of evidence. Yes, and very easy to verify or debunk, all Reuters had to do was contact me and ask to see the recording, as the Epoch Times reporter did. That was all (basic journalism standards).

The Epoch Times saw the full recording and translated it into English.

fact checker

According to a WhatsApp message reviewed by The Epoch Times, a person named Anat Koren, who identified himself as working for Reuters as a fact-checker, reviewed a video clip posted online, but said the full video was not available. I never asked for it. Reuters did not deny that Coren worked for the company.

Coren was also given Berkovich’s number, but Reuters did not disclose whether Berkovich had been contacted in the article.

Koren also said Reuters cannot publish the story unless the health ministry responds. The video first leaked in August, and Coren became aware of the clip that month.

“My hands are tied. It’s owned by Reuters. It’s up to them what they publish. I’m just a fact-finding investigator. The Ministry of Health has not responded yet,” she said, soon after. It added that it had heard back, but the health ministry was “not willing to comment at this time”.

“It’s not part of my job to decide what to publish. In fact, if it doesn’t contradict what you post, we have no lawsuit,” Coren said in a message exchanged with Levi. rice field.

According to the message, Koren was unaware that the Israeli system was different from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System, a US government adverse event reporting system that allows users to submit reports anonymously. She also didn’t know that some countries were compensating people injured by her COVID-19 vaccine.

Zachary Stever


Zachary Stieber covers US and world news for The Epoch Times. He is based in Maryland.

Leah Onelly


Lia Onely reports from Israel for The Epoch Times.