Oklahoma Attorney General urges the Supreme Court to overturn a groundbreaking decision on tribal sovereignty


Oklahoma Lawyer President Asked the Supreme Court On Friday, he claimed that the decision led to a “criminal justice crisis” to overturn the 2020 ruling affirming tribal sovereignty.

Important reason: The petition was issued the day after Patrick Murphy, a convict on death row in Oklahoma, was again convicted in federal court for murder and kidnapping. AP report..

Get the right market news for your time at Axios Markets. Subscribe for free.

Newly appointed Oklahoma Attorney General John O’Connor has petitioned that thousands of state prisoners have challenged decades-old convictions in a High Court ruling, many of which cannot be prosecuted again. Insist.

context: The Supreme Court ruled last year that much of eastern Oklahoma remains a Native American reservation. That is, the Oklahoma prosecutor was not authorized to file criminal charges against Murphy.

  • “This decision has led thousands of crime victims to seek justice from federal and tribal prosecutors who are not equipped to handle these requests,” the petition said. ..

  • “Many crimes have not been investigated or investigated, endangering public safety.”

What they are saying: O’Connor’s petition requires the Supreme Court to consider narrowing the application of the sentence so that violent criminals convicted prior to the sentence can remain in state prisons.

Opposite side: Some tribal lawyers say state warnings have been exaggerated and federal and tribal courts are trying to control the number of cases.

  • Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt (R) has accused Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt of pursuing an “anti-Indian political agenda.”

  • “The governor has never tried to work with the tribes to protect all Oklahomans,” Hoskin said in a statement. “It is perfectly clear that it was always his intention to destroy the Oklahoma settlement and the sovereignty of the Oklahoma tribe, no matter how much it cost.”

Our Fukidashi Park: Native American activists say that if state authorities want to prosecute non-tribal members, the state should sign an agreement with the tribe rather than trying to overturn tribal sovereignty over the federal government, said Russell Contreras of Axios. Stated.

  • Brett Chapman, a lawyer for Tulsa, a registered member of the Pawnee tribe, said state officials were hostile and were trying to ignore tribal sovereignty. “McGirt is a law of land and they need to overcome it,” he told Axios.

Notable: O’Connor filed a petition in connection with Sean Bosse’s case. Bosse, a convict on death row, was convicted of killing his girlfriend and two children in 2010.

  • Bosse is not a tribal citizen, but his victims were tribal citizens and the killings took place in the Chica Sonation settlement.

Do you like this article? Get more from Axios, Subscribe to Axios Markets for free.