-
A Washington couple is suing a fertility clinic for destroying seven embryos.
-
The clinic admitted that there was an error in the storage of embryos and they would dry out and die.
-
Law firms representing couples say the fertility industry is less regulated than salons.
KaraSeldin-Howell and Kolton Howell have always wanted a child. However, after getting married and buying a house, they found it harder than expected to get pregnant.
Their doctor is a Washington-based couple In vitro fertilization They sought consultation with fertility clinics across the country before settling in CNY fertility clinics, as it is the best way to start a family.
“Looking back, I regret that decision,” said Seldin Howell. Said at a press conference on Wednesday..
After the couple received In vitro fertilization mental and physical excretion process — Including invasive tests, hormone injections, and surgical procedures to remove Seldin Howell’s eggs before mixing them with Howell’s sperm in the laboratory — they know they have created seven viable embryos. I was delighted.
Video: Fertility Expert Uncovers Pregnancy Myths
But just two days later (the day before Mother’s Day 2021), their fertility doctor, Dr. Paul Magalelli, said the embryos were destroyed. After investigating the reason, Magalelli told the couple that a clinic expert learned that the necessary oil was not in the Petri dish and the embryos would dry out and die.
“Within 48 hours, we were overjoyed that our dream of starting a family had finally come true, and we were separated from us,” Howell said. .. “Almost a year later, I’m still struggling to handle what happened.”
Couples represented by Peiffer Wolf Carr Kane & Conway CNY Fertility Sue Colorado The parent company, CNY Fertility, operates other fertility clinics in New York, Pennsylvania, Florida, Georgia and Canada. They claim negligence, breach of contract, lack of informed consent, and other allegations.
CNY Fertility Colorado did not immediately respond to insider comment requests.
Couple still wants kids
At a press conference, Seldin Howell said she and her husband still wanted to have a family, but they haven’t been able to move forward yet.
“This experience definitely upset our journey to become a parent,” she said, saying they lost valuable time both in recovering from what happened after in vitro fertilization. rice field.
Another round of in vitro fertilization isn’t off the table, but “we can’t say we’re not afraid of something similar,” Seldin-Howell said. “We are traumatized by this experience.”
She said that the only comfort Magalelli gave them was not their fault, but would require staff to “reconfirm” the embryo storage protocol in the future. According to their lawyers, the potential compensation provided was not sufficient to avoid the proceedings.
“These embryos were our future babies until CNY’s fertility inadvertently destroyed them,” said Seldin-Howell. “I feel deprived of our time, our resources, and the blood, sweat, and tears we have invested in this process, and most importantly, start our future and our families. I was robbed of our dream. “
This case is one of many cases that show that law firms say they are an under-regulated industry.
Peiffer Wolf Carr Kane & Conway says he has handled hundreds of cases of fertility center fraud.
In 2021 LA couple sued fertility clinic After a misplaced embryo causes another couple’s children to become pregnant and the couple becomes pregnant and begins to grow.That year, another family claimed that their adult daughter was now pregnant after a fertility doctor. I used my sperm for treatment Without consent.
Earlier this year Two alleged women They were switched at birth 57 years ago. This was discovered by a DNA test.
In 2019, Peiffer Wolf Domestic law For better surveillance of IVF and fertility clinics, it says it is less regulated than hairdressers and beauty salons.
There is no government agency to oversee Fertility industryIncludes nearly 500 clinics and centers.This means that no one controls how fertility centers label tissues such as embryos and disciplinary centers that do not comply with expert guidelines, NBC News. report..
The scale of self-regulation is Assisted Reproductive Technology Society According to PeifferWolf’s partner Adam Wolf, it’s a non-profit organization that requires member organizations to promote the truth, report results accurately, and work with nationally accredited laboratories.
“I’m still confused by this preventable tragedy,” he said Wednesday. “The reaction of CNY Fertility’s’Hoop. I’ll do my best next time’should confuse all of us.”
Read the original article insider